February 17, 2019

Gender Commission take on bastion of patriarchy

The Commission on Gender Equality (CGE) has completed an investigation into transformation in the mining industry ‑ and found few signs of change.

The Systemic Investigation into Mining, conducted in 2015 and released in the 2016/17 financial year, set out to investigate the challenges that continue to face women in the sector. It was also prompted by observations that the disabled face similar obstacles in this industry.

In its report to the Portfolio Committee on Women in the Presidency, presented at Parliament this week, the CGE stated, “Despite all the various legislative, policy and other instruments promoting gender mainstreaming and transformation, progress has been extremely slow in the mining sector.”

Not unexpectedly, the research found that women and the disabled faced entrenched attitudes at all levels in the industry. Women in Mining SA (WIMSA) is reported as confirming that for a woman to reach a more senior level in mining, she has to prove that she is a cut above male applicants.

Despite promoting gender mainstreaming transformation has been extremely slow in the mining sector.

The research confirms common knowledge. This sector has always been a man’s world, and despite pressures for change it appears to be one of the last to show a willingness to shift. This is grossly simplifying the main finding of the CGE research, but sums it up accurately.

The study lists all the legislation and the international conventions that South Africa subscribes to in its commitment to gender equality. Few seem to have made an impact on the mining sector. Despite the Labour Relations Act of 1995, the Commission for Gender Equality Act of 1996; the Basic Conditions of Employment Act of 1997; the Employment Equity Act as amended in 1998; the Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act of 2000, the industry continues to resist change.

There is also the Broad Based Economic Empowerment Act of 2003, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Preferential Procurement Act 5, the Mineral Petroleum Resources Development Act and of course the Mining Charter. All these make provisions for a shift to include women’s participation, but mining seems determined to look the other way.

Employers in this sector continue to fail or neglect to comply with these obligations. So much so that one of the stated objectives of the investigation was to ascertain the reasons why, despite the extensive barrage of legislation and conventions, this industry remains particularly stubborn and unreceptive to change.

The report went on to say that existing evidence shows that women, especially underground workers, face practical challenges and safety issues on a daily basis, “such as verbal/sexual harassment and physical abuse”.

Women mineworkers have to wear protective gear that is designed for men and is not “comfortable or practical for women. In many cases, women do not have separate toilet facilities especially underground, which increases risks of sexual assault/rape.” Elsewhere it reports, “In some instances, women in mining are pressured to offer sexual favours for promotion”.

CGE has spent six years tracking gender transformation in the economy. It has devised a tool, the Gender Barometer, with which it has conducted regular annual assessments of public sector institution. In 2015 it turned its attention to the private sector for the first time and targeted mining.

Why mining? Its report explains: “South Africa has made great progress in promoting gender equality; however the traditional image of the mining sector, underpinned by strong and persistent perceptions that the sector remains a strong domain of male dominance and privilege, and is considered unsuitable for women, persists.”

The CGE is not only suggesting that women are able to do underground work other than “soft” support roles. It is asking why this sector, which is an important sector of the economy in terms of employment rates and foreign exchange earnings, has so few women in its boardrooms. You don’t have to have the physical strength to operate a drill in order to take a seat among the directors.

To determine why mining remains impervious to gender change, questionnaires were sent to Anglo American and three of its subsidiaries and African Rainbow Minerals Group and three of its subsidiaries. The aim was to get a comprehensive picture by including a new black economic empowerment group and a large, well-established institution.

No surprises in the findings. Both companies confirmed what we already know – that mining ownership remains in the hands of the few, and they play golf together. And it appears women, men of colour and the disabled don’t get invitations to golf.

“There is a vast representation of previously disadvantaged groups at the lower, non-decision-making levels of management in the two mining houses,” the report states.

The CGE report includes four pages of recommendations, starting with the innovative idea that providing childcare facilities might ease the way for female representation. It goes on to suggest that placing women in acting positions and including them in the bursary programmes would also help, as would workshops across the industry to develop awareness workshops around sexual harassment and gender equality.

These aren’t new ideas, and the CGE was not the first to come up with them. But you have to hand it to them. They are the ones who continue to pursue them, and by taking on the mining industry this Commission is showing what it is made of.

Moira Levy

Additional Info

  • Author: Moira Levy
Last modified on Tuesday, 16 January 2018 18:20

About Us

Notes from the House is an independent weekly email newsletter that tracks and monitors Parliament in its role of holding government to account and passing legislation to improve people’s lives. It aims to bring you the news from Parliament that you don’t get elsewhere. Published by Moira Levy with the support of the Claude Leon Foundation.

Latest Tweets

@gwedemantashe held a meeting with a company that wants to extend mining on the west coast. Turns out to be the sam… https://t.co/MWfQOEgeHs
Land expropriation without compensation is not going to be the answer to land redistribution. Thanks to PLAAS and o… https://t.co/WDiDCXENlB
Follow Notes from the House on Twitter